There’s a unique intimacy found in silence between two people, in the subtle glances and unspoken understanding. This is brilliantly captured in “All of You,” where Simon (Brett Goldstein) and Laura (Imogen Poots) share many such quiet moments, allowing us to deeply feel the profound connection that binds them.
This film delivers a sweeping, emotional romance across many years and relationship challenges. While it openly embraces its ‘weepy love story’ identity, it never feels forced, thanks entirely to the superb performances of Goldstein and Poots. Their natural charm and easy chemistry – reminiscent of best friends finally realizing their deeper feelings – makes their complex journey as lovers incredibly believable, even when their choices are questionable.
Directed by William Bridges, who also co-wrote the script with Goldstein, “All of You” is set in a near-future where ‘The Test’ promises to definitively identify your perfect soul mate. Despite his skepticism, Simon convinces Laura to take the test, only for it to reveal a shocking outcome: Simon is not her destined match.
This intriguing premise, featuring AI-driven soulmate matching, ultimately serves as a clever backdrop rather than the main event. The true heart of the film lies in Simon and Laura’s evolving relationship, which unfolds over many years and significant life events. The narrative skillfully jumps through time, relying on Goldstein and Poots to convey the shifting dynamics and enduring unspoken affection between their characters, which they execute with remarkable depth.
Goldstein effortlessly delivers sharp, witty dialogue, injecting humor into potentially dull scenes. His character also reveals a disarming vulnerability that adds layers to his seemingly stoic facade. However, it is Poots who truly shines. Her grounded, magnetic performance avoids the typical romantic comedy pitfalls of forced quirkiness or cynical snark. Crucially, her subtle portrayal of inner struggle and emotional aging provides the film with its most powerful and resonant impact.
Laura’s emotional journey takes the narrative beyond the usual romantic drama tropes. Despite its sci-fi leanings, “All of You” isn’t just about finding soul mates or the grand mysteries of love. Instead, it bravely explores the poignant realities of enduring affection and the harsh challenges life throws at two people trying to stay connected.
A pivotal scene sees Laura recounting her discovery of old letters between her father and a secret love, regretting that he never pursued his ‘true love.’ Simon offers a sobering perspective: her father already had a wife and daughter. His simple, honest reply — ‘That’s how life is, isn’t it?’ — encapsulates the film’s mature take on love and commitment.
All of You
Rated R for sexual content, nudity, language and brief drug use. Running time: 1 hour 38 minutes.