My sister lost her husband to cancer two years ago, and a month after his passing, she began sending me hurtful and accusatory letters. Her anger stems from various issues. One main point of contention is my inability to travel 3,000 miles to be with her during his six-month illness and treatment. Another revolves around an older family disagreement where she felt I was unfairly upset. She has accused my husband and me of not caring about her late husband, which is far from the truth. We deeply cared, sending her thoughtful gifts, letters, and messages throughout that incredibly difficult period.
These letters, arriving roughly every four months, left me stunned. I initially replied to each one, only to receive another belittling response. Eventually, I realized it was futile and stopped writing back. My sister insists I should call her to ‘fix’ everything, but I dread the idea, fearing more of the same hurtful accusations. My other two sisters also urge me to call, reasoning that she’s ‘grieving’ and therefore justified in sending any kind of letter she chooses.
This raises a crucial question: Does grief give someone permission to insult and belittle a sibling so cruelly?
From the Therapist: It’s clear both you and your sister share a common thread: a sense of being unfairly treated or misunderstood. She feels you were ‘unfairly upset’ in a past family matter, and you feel she’s unfairly upset about your efforts to support her during her husband’s illness.
These kinds of disagreements are a normal part of any relationship. We inevitably disappoint those we love, and often believe we wouldn’t react the same way if roles were reversed. However, genuine repair isn’t about proving who’s right or wrong. It’s about stepping into the other person’s experience, understanding them as an individual separate from yourself. We bridge the gap not by forcing identical feelings, but by reaching out and conveying a simple message: I care about your well-being.
You can begin to heal with your sister by re-examining how you perceive this situation. The words we use heavily influence our conclusions. You describe her letters as ‘insulting’ and ‘cruel,’ and question if grief permits belittling a sibling. But consider whether your sister is truly making malicious statements (e.g., ‘You’re a horrible person!’), or if she’s expressing profound hurt and a feeling of being unsupported during what was likely the worst period of her life.
Feeling hurt or disappointed isn’t an insult in itself; it’s a raw emotional experience. And expressing that experience—even if you disagree with its basis, even if it feels unfair, and even if it seems to ignore your sincere efforts—isn’t inherently cruel. It’s also possible that her initial attempts to articulate her pain escalated into heated letters because you may have inadvertently failed to acknowledge her underlying feelings. While this doesn’t excuse cruelty, it’s important not to mistake her deep anguish for malice.
You feel attacked because you genuinely cared for her husband and demonstrated that care through letters, gifts, and messages. Yet, as often happens during crises, clear communication can break down.
Perhaps she expected you, as her sister, to instinctively know she needed your physical presence and hoped you would arrive without being asked. Or perhaps she did ask, but your circumstances prevented you from being there for reasons that feel understandable to you. Regardless of your intentions, your absence during her husband’s illness seems to have been perceived as abandonment.
When someone voices feelings of being ‘unsupported,’ the natural inclination is often to defend, justify, or withdraw. All these reactions only serve to make that person feel even more unheard. Your replies to her letters might have sounded less like empathy (‘I understand how much you wished I could be there’) and more like a defense (‘We did care, we sent things, we checked in’). This could be why she continues to reiterate the same complaints: she’s not looking for an explanation; she’s seeking validation. You needed this. You didn’t get it. Period.
Acknowledging her feelings doesn’t equate to agreeing with her accusations. It means creating space for her emotions without admitting to indifference. And since your attempts to exonerate yourself haven’t been effective, try a different approach, something along these lines:
‘In re-reading our letters, I truly hear the immense pain my absence caused, and I am so sorry I wasn’t there in the way you needed me. I love you very much. Please, let’s connect on a video call and talk.’
A video call is preferable because written correspondence can entrench positions, whereas seeing each other’s faces and hearing voices can restore a sense of humanity. Your goal in this conversation won’t be to defend your past actions or set the record straight. Instead, it will be to listen to her disappointment without trying to make it disappear. She may never fully accept your reasons for not being there during her husband’s final months. You, in turn, might never believe her expectations were entirely reasonable during that time. But you have a choice: you can either draw closer by offering a sincere apology for her pain, or risk a permanent rift by insisting she shouldn’t feel the way she does.
This brings us back to your shared experience. What transpires between you now is less about the past and more about the future you wish to build together. Your willingness to validate her feelings might encourage her to acknowledge yours regarding the other family matter. This could pave the way for a new pattern of relating—one that allows you to navigate differences with a positive and lasting impact on your relationship.
Her husband’s death is a stark reminder of life’s brevity. How do you want to reflect on this moment in your relationship? Will it be the time you apologized for not being there in the way she needed, or the time you continued to argue your reasonable decision while she remained hurt? These are the crucial junctures where families either mend or fracture.
Time is precious. Don’t wait too long to make your choice.
Want to Ask the Therapist? If you have a question, you can submit it to the column. Please be aware of the submission guidelines. This column offers general advice and is not a substitute for professional medical guidance.