On October 16, French Prime Minister Sebastien Lecornu barely scraped through two no-confidence votes in the National Assembly, narrowly escaping an immediate government collapse. This offered a brief moment of relief amidst France’s deepening political crisis.
Motions brought by the far-left La France Insoumise (LFI) and the far-right National Rally (RN) secured 271 and 197 votes respectively, falling just 18 votes short of the 289 required to oust the government. While a technical victory for both Mr. Lecornu and President Emmanuel Macron, this outcome starkly highlights the precarious position of their minority government in a fiercely divided Parliament.
Lecornu’s narrow escape was largely due to strategic compromises, notably the temporary halt of Macron’s contentious pension reform and a commitment to avoid using Article 49.3 – a constitutional mechanism often criticized as undemocratic for allowing bills to pass without a parliamentary vote. This uneasy truce, solidified by the Socialist Party’s abstention following the pension reform freeze, provided a fragile, fleeting unity in the midst of France’s escalating political disarray.
The origins of France’s political upheaval can be traced to June 2024. After a crushing defeat to Marine Le Pen’s National Rally (RN) in the European Parliament election, President Macron impulsively called snap legislative elections, hoping to reassert his authority. However, no single bloc achieved an absolute majority in the 577-seat National Assembly. The left-wing New Popular Front (NFP) alliance became the largest faction with approximately 180 seats, followed by Macron’s centrist Ensemble coalition with 163, and Le Pen’s RN with 143. Smaller centrist and conservative parties divided the remaining seats, resulting in a hung parliament and a subsequent succession of short-lived governments, each brought down by no-confidence threats or resignations.
Macron’s Rocky Second Term
President Macron’s second term, commencing in 2022, has been plagued by relentless crises. His 2023 pension reform, which increased the retirement age from 62 to 64, ignited months of widespread strikes and protests across the nation. This particular measure, controversially forced through using Article 49.3, epitomized executive hubris and a disregard for democratic process. Since 2022, five Prime Ministers have occupied Matignon, each tenure cut short by fractured coalitions, budget stalemates, and looming no-confidence votes. Such persistent instability has severely damaged public trust, making France’s governance appear remarkably dysfunctional compared to its European counterparts.
Compounding this unrest, economic anxieties have intensified the national malaise. Statista data reveals that public debt has soared to 114% of GDP, well beyond EU fiscal limits. Opinion polls from Ifop indicate a mere 19% public satisfaction with Macron’s performance, the lowest since his presidency began in 2017. Once celebrated as Europe’s pragmatic reformer, Macron has become entrenched in the image of the “President of the rich,” facing widespread accusations of economic missteps and political arrogance.
The Immediate Catalyst for Crisis
The proximate cause of the October crisis was the tumultuous appointment of Mr. Lecornu, which occurred after Francois Bayrou’s resignation in September. Bayrou, a seasoned centrist and former Macron ally, stepped down having failed to assemble a government capable of passing the 2026 Budget. With a critical October 15 deadline looming for submitting fiscal plans to the EU, Macron reluctantly turned to Lecornu, his steadfast Defence Minister and trusted confidant.
Lecornu’s early days in office, however, proved to be nothing short of chaotic. The 39-year-old was appointed on September 9 with the mandate to restore stability to a presidency losing its hold. Yet, his government lasted barely four weeks; he resigned on October 6, just 26 days into the role, only to be reappointed a mere four days later. This entire episode, widely derided as political farce, further diminished public confidence. Marine Le Pen famously declared it “the end of the joke,” demanding the dissolution of the National Assembly. Outgoing Minister Agnes Pannier-Runacher openly criticized the “circus” of French politics, while Socialist MP Arthur Delaporte starkly stated: “Macronism is plunging the country into chaos.”
When Lecornu unveiled his austerity-heavy budget proposal, opposition parties quickly capitalized on the opportunity. LFI’s no-confidence motion fiercely condemned the social spending cuts as an assault on workers, while RN’s motion critiqued the government’s perceived “disorder” and immigration stances. Though both motions failed, the ensuing debates laid bare the profound national discontent and the seemingly insurmountable challenge of achieving stable governance without genuine coalition-building.
Macron’s Singular Loyalty
Macron’s selection of Lecornu was a clear testament to his prioritization of loyalty. A former Republican, Lecornu transitioned to Macron’s centrist movement in 2017, building a strong reputation for pragmatism and unwavering support. During his tenure as Minister of the Armed Forces, he oversaw France’s critical aid to Ukraine and upheld defense readiness despite tight budgetary limitations.
Strategically, Lecornu’s provincial background and administrative experience were intended to soften Macron’s image as an aloof, out-of-touch Parisian elite.
Nevertheless, many critics viewed this appointment as further evidence of Macron’s insulated decision-making. Lecornu’s brief resignation and subsequent re-appointment only amplified public perceptions of governmental dysfunction and indecisiveness. His narrow victory in October starkly highlights the minimal margin for error that now remains.
Mounting Pressure on Macron
Concurrently, the pressure on President Macron’s administration continues to intensify. Politically, he finds himself increasingly isolated. Opposition leaders are openly calling for snap elections or even his resignation, while even former key allies, like ex-Prime Minister Edouard Philippe, have publicly distanced themselves from the Élysée Palace. From Marine Le Pen of the National Rally to Jean-Luc Mélenchon of LFI, influential figures across the spectrum are demanding fundamental systemic change and a “Sixth Republic” to curtail presidential authority.
Public sentiment mirrors this hostility. On social media, “Macron’s chaos” has become a trending phrase, perfectly capturing the widespread frustration with the incessant cycle of resignations, crises, and parliamentary stalemates. France, once a proud beacon of stable democracy, now endures ridicule both domestically and internationally. Despite these persistent calls for his resignation and fresh elections, President Macron remains resolute, vowing to complete his full term.
During a Gaza peace summit in Egypt on October 13, Macron appealed for “stability over chaos,” squarely blaming his political adversaries for undermining Lecornu’s initial cabinet.
Lecornu’s Precarious Path Forward
For Prime Minister Lecornu, the road ahead is fraught with danger. His commitment to temporarily suspend pension reform might calm public anger for now, but it risks alienating fiscal conservatives and EU partners who are pushing for stringent budget consolidation. Simultaneously, the impending 2026 Budget negotiations will severely test his capacity to forge consensus among diametrically opposed political factions.
While Lecornu’s background in defense and local governance could be valuable in crisis management, legislative gridlock remains his critical vulnerability. Any strategic error could easily spark fresh no-confidence votes or even force early elections.
France’s immediate future precariously balances on Lecornu’s ability to reconcile fiscal discipline with social stability. The left champions wealth taxes and increased social spending, while the right advocates for austerity and stricter migration controls. Crucially, neither side seems inclined to compromise.
Should Lecornu fail to pass the 2026 Budget, France could face automatic spending rollovers, significant EU fines, or even detrimental credit downgrades. Furthermore, as living costs continue to climb and unemployment remains stubborn, widespread protests could easily erupt once more. Concurrently, Macron’s diminishing influence within the EU poses a serious threat to France’s traditional leadership position in Europe. Without a renewed sense of legitimacy, whether achieved through a stable governing coalition or fresh elections, France stands on the brink of sinking deeper into an acute governability crisis.