A momentous agreement has been reached between Israel and Hamas: an exchange of Israeli hostages for Palestinian prisoners. This breakthrough marks a potential turning point in the devastating, two-year-long conflict in Gaza.
President Trump, a key mediator in these negotiations, announced on social media that both parties have accepted the initial phase of his peace proposal. This phase mandates a pullback of Israeli troops to a designated line. President Trump also hinted at a possible visit to the region this weekend, where Gaza negotiations were actively taking place in Sharm el-Sheikh, Egypt.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu confirmed his plan to convene his cabinet to formally approve the agreement. The Israeli military has expressed its support and is preparing for the return of the hostages and a strategic repositioning of its forces.
“With God’s help we will bring them all home,” Mr. Netanyahu stated.
Unresolved Complexities
Crucially, some of the most challenging issues remain untouched, deferred to future negotiation phases. These include the long-term governance of postwar Gaza and the extent to which Hamas might disarm.
In Gaza, where widespread food shortages have led international experts to declare a famine in part of the territory, aid organizations are hopeful that this agreement will enable them to accelerate the delivery of desperately needed supplies to the population.
Hamas, in an early Thursday statement, affirmed that the agreement would lead to the cessation of hostilities in Gaza and Israel’s full withdrawal. Both Hamas and Qatar, a mediating country, also confirmed that the deal would facilitate increased humanitarian aid flow into Gaza. Hamas urged President Trump and other international actors to ensure Israel’s complete and timely implementation of the agreement’s terms.
However, hours after President Trump’s announcement, the Israeli military issued a statement to Gaza residents, emphasizing that Israeli troops still maintained their presence and that the conflict was ongoing.
Background to the Conflict and Negotiations
The war began in October 2023 with a Hamas-led attack on Israel, which resulted in approximately 1,200 deaths, mostly civilians, and the capture of about 250 hostages. In response, the Israeli military operation has caused the deaths of over 67,000 Palestinians, including civilians and combatants, according to the Gaza health ministry, and has left much of Gaza’s infrastructure in ruins.
After months of deadlocked cease-fire talks, Hamas indicated last week its readiness to release all Israeli hostages in Gaza, in line with the peace plan proposed by President Trump on September 29. Israel estimates that around 20 living hostages and the remains of 28 deceased individuals are still being held. The release of the living Israeli hostages is expected as early as this weekend, possibly on Sunday, according to an anonymous official involved in the diplomatic efforts.
Key Aspects of the Agreement and its Implications
Uncertain Details
Many specifics of the agreement remain undisclosed. Officials have not provided precise information regarding the exchange ratio of hostages for prisoners or the exact withdrawal lines for Israeli forces. It’s also uncertain if this agreement will lead to a permanent end to the war, particularly given Hamas’s public refusal to disarm, a key demand from Prime Minister Netanyahu.
Hope for Gazans
Palestinians in Gaza welcomed the news with profound hope that their two-year ordeal might finally conclude. Montaser Bahja, an English teacher displaced in Khan Younis, expressed a mix of “joy for the end of the war and the killing, and sorrow for everything we’ve lost.” He noted that people were keenly following the news, awaiting the effective start of a truce.
International Endorsement
Israeli President Isaac Herzog publicly stated his belief that President Trump merited the Nobel Peace Prize for his role in brokering the deal. The Nobel Peace Prize winner for 2025 is scheduled to be announced on Friday.
Trump’s 20-Point Peace Plan
President Trump’s comprehensive 20-point peace plan includes provisions that Hamas has historically rejected, suggesting these could become future hurdles to achieving a lasting peace. The plan outlines conditions such as Hamas disarming and having no role in Gaza’s governance, replaced by a “technocratic, apolitical Palestinian committee” with international oversight. It also proposes the redevelopment of Gaza as a “de-radicalized terror-free zone.” Critically, it emphasizes that Israel will not occupy or annex Gaza and will withdraw based on agreed-upon demilitarization timelines. While the plan seeks to establish a dialogue for peaceful coexistence, it does not explicitly guarantee a Palestinian state, only a “credible pathway to Palestinian self-determination and statehood.”
Pressure on Israel
A pivotal moment leading to this agreement was Israel’s September 9 strike targeting Hamas representatives in Qatar. This action, while not killing the negotiators, provoked strong reactions in the Middle East and Washington, initially threatening peace prospects. However, it ultimately spurred President Trump and his advisors to exert significant pressure on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu to support a framework for ending the conflict.
The Path to a Deal
The negotiations that transformed stalled talks into a concrete deal involved intense mediation by countries like Qatar, Egypt, and the United States. Following the Qatar bombing incident, which strained relations, President Trump used his influence to push for a resolution. He outlined his 20-point plan at the White House with Prime Minister Netanyahu present, and subsequently pressured Hamas to accept the terms by a Sunday evening deadline. Both sides eventually agreed to the initial steps, surprising many and highlighting the severe impact of the war on Gaza and the diminishing support for Hamas among its population.
The Hostage Situation
President Trump prioritized the release of Israeli hostages as a central component of the cease-fire efforts. Hamas and other militant groups captured approximately 250 people during the October 7, 2023, attack on Israel. While many have been freed through previous exchanges for Palestinian prisoners or Israeli military operations, around 20 living hostages and the remains of 28 others are believed to still be in Gaza. The new agreement outlines a process where Israel would release 250 life-sentence prisoners and 1,700 Gazans detained after October 7, 2023, along with the remains of 15 deceased Gazans for every Israeli hostage’s remains returned. The exact timing for these releases is still being determined.
Ongoing Developments
-
Egyptian Aid: Egypt’s state-run Al Qahera News reported an aid convoy entering Gaza from Egypt, coinciding with the agreement announcement, signaling continued efforts to deliver relief.
-
Military Preparations: The Israeli military has announced preparations to implement the agreement and “transition to adjusted deployment lines soon.”
-
Palestinian Authority’s Stance: Mahmoud Abbas, the Palestinian Authority president, welcomed the agreement, expressing hope for a lasting political solution that includes ending the Israeli occupation and establishing an independent Palestinian state with East Jerusalem as its capital. He commended President Trump and all mediators for their efforts.
-
Gaza Awaits Truce: Residents in Israel and Gaza woke up to the news of the agreement with a mix of anticipation and hope, eagerly awaiting details on when a truce would officially take effect.
-
Uncertain Future: Despite the initial agreement, the path to a complete and lasting peace remains uncertain. The history of the region suggests that while truces can be reached, the underlying conflicts are deeply entrenched and complex to resolve permanently.